Choosing a London Renovation Contractor: Comparing Quotes
Check a renovation contractor's references, insurance and project evidence, then compare London building quotes on scope, allowances, VAT and payment terms.

Choosing a renovation contractor involves two separate checks. First, can this business demonstrate that it is suitable for your project? Second, does its quotation cover the work you actually want?
A reassuring conversation does not replace a clear specification. Equally, a detailed price does not replace checking the people who will carry out the work.
Whether you are refurbishing a Richmond house, changing a kitchen layout in East Sheen or renovating elsewhere in South West London, use both checks before appointing a contractor.
Check who you are contracting with
Confirm the business's legal identity and make sure the quotation, contract, insurance and payment arrangements are consistent with it. If something does not match, ask for an explanation before paying.
For a limited company, use the free Companies House register to check its status, officers, filing history, previous names and registered office. Registration alone does not demonstrate building competence or the quality of its work, and Companies House does not verify the accuracy of everything filed.
Ask who will manage your project each day, who your main contact will be and which work will be subcontracted. You should understand the team you are appointing, not only the person who attended the first visit.
Look for relevant project evidence
Ask for examples that resemble your proposed work. A decorative refresh does not demonstrate the same experience as structural alterations and a full refurbishment.
Finished photographs are useful, but ask what the contractor actually delivered. Were they responsible for the whole project or one part of it?
With the clients' agreement, speak to recent references. Useful questions include:
- Did the written scope match the work delivered?
- How were additional costs explained and approved?
- Who communicated decisions and programme changes?
- How were neighbouring properties and occupied rooms considered?
- What happened when snagging or defects needed attention?
You can see examples of the work we document on our Wimbledon whole-house renovation, Chiswick townhouse renovation, Wandsworth rear extension and two-house refurbishment in Fulham pages. Ask any shortlisted contractor for similarly attributable evidence and clarify whether it delivered the whole project or only one part.
Check insurance and membership claims
Ask for current insurance information and check the insured business name, policy dates, scope and limits. Discuss public liability, employers' liability where required, and responsibility for insuring the works and existing building. Government guidance states that qualifying employers normally need at least £5 million of employers' liability cover from an authorised insurer.
Your own home insurer may also need to know about the proposed work. Check before the project starts rather than assuming your existing cover remains unchanged.
Verify membership claims with the relevant organisation. Bluebird Spaces is listed by the Federation of Master Builders. A badge is supporting information, not a substitute for references, appropriate insurance and a written contract. Gas work should be carried out by someone on the Gas Safe Register, and you can check whether an insurer or intermediary is authorised on the Financial Services Register.
Give every builder the same information
Prices are only comparable when they are based on the same brief.
Send each contractor the same drawings, with revision dates, the same specification and the same room-by-room scope. State which products you will supply and whether the house will remain occupied.
If a design changes during the quotation process, issue the update to everyone. Otherwise, one builder may be pricing a different project without either of you realising.
Compare the quotation line by line
Use these checks before judging the total:
Scope and finishing
Does the price include strip-out, structural work, service alterations, plastering, decoration, flooring and making good? Which rooms and surfaces are covered?
“Kitchen installation” might not include supplying the kitchen, appliances, worktops, electrical changes or decoration. Ask rather than assuming.
VAT and exclusions
Is VAT included or excluded? Are design, engineering, building-control and party-wall costs included? What about scaffolding, waste removal, protection and access arrangements?
Do not treat an excluded item as unnecessary simply because it is absent from the total.
Provisional and prime cost sums
A provisional sum generally allows for work that is not yet fully defined. A prime cost allowance commonly relates to products that have not been selected. The precise treatment depends on the contract.
Ask what each allowance covers, whether installation and associated charges are included, and how differences will be agreed. A low allowance can make a headline price appear attractive without reducing the cost of the finished project.
Supply responsibilities
Record who supplies, measures, orders, receives and installs major items. Agree what happens if a client-supplied product arrives late, damaged or unsuitable.
Agree changes, payments and programme in writing
The contract should explain how a change is described, priced and approved, including its effect on the programme. Avoid relying on a conversation that neither side has recorded.
Understand what each payment covers and when it becomes due. Ask for clear milestones or descriptions of completed work. There is no single payment structure that you should assume applies to every contractor.
If advance money is requested for particular orders, ask what it buys, who owns the items and what protection applies if circumstances change. Bluebird's stated approach is no deposit upfront and weekly payments for completed work. Under the Consumer Rights Act 2015, a trader supplying a service must perform it with reasonable care and skill.
Also record the programme assumptions: access, design decisions, product lead times, permissions and any client responsibilities. The Health and Safety Executive requires a construction phase plan for every construction project; for domestic work, the contractor or principal contractor normally prepares it. Where relevant, discuss neighbouring-owner procedures early; our party wall notice timeline explains why they need planning ahead.
Do not choose on the lowest total alone
A cheaper quotation may represent better value. It may also leave more work undefined. The task is to establish which explanation applies.
Pause if a contractor will not explain significant exclusions, identify the priced drawings, provide relevant references or put agreed terms in writing. Clarify those points before making a commitment.
Frequently asked questions
How many renovation quotes should I obtain?
Get a manageable shortlist of detailed proposals based on the same information. Comparable scope matters more than collecting a large number of headline figures.
Does a fixed-price quote prevent additional charges?
It fixes the price for the agreed work on the stated terms. Client changes, excluded work and unforeseen conditions need to be dealt with through the contract's agreed process.
What if the quotes are very different?
Ask each contractor to explain its scope and assumptions. Compare missing work, allowances, finishes, VAT and programme constraints before negotiating the total.
For your next step, read about our house renovations and request a site visit.
Free site visit, then a fixed-price quote. No obligation.
